Pillow: OOB read in TiffDecode.c tile and RGBA paths leaks heap memory into pixels

The ~400-byte TIFF tile_count2.tif generated by the reproducer — one 16x16 tile, BitsPerSample 8, SamplesPerPixel 1, Compression 8 (Adobe Deflate), and PhotometricInterpretation written as a SHORT with count 2 (6, 6) — is opened by Image.open() as mode RGB with libtiff rawmode RGBX, and load() succeeds on the stock build. Rows 13–15 of the result contain bytes that lie 16, 32 and 48 bytes past the 256-byte tile buffer: decoding the same file twice under MALLOC_PERTURB_=85 and =170 yields identical rows 0–12 and different bytes in rows 13–15 (aa vs 55, i.e. glibc's fill pattern). Under an ASan build of the extensions the same load() reports heap-buffer-overflow READ of size 64 in copy4 (src/libImaging/Unpack.c:1290) called from src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c:483, against the 256-byte region allocated at TiffDecode.c:448. The same layout with a single 65536x16 tile (4.5 KB file) makes the stock build SIGSEGV in copy4 ← _decodeTile reading an unmapped address in most runs (whether it faults depends on what is mapped after the 1 MiB buffer; a wider tile makes it reliable).

Why the two parsers disagree

libtiff 4.5 rejects a PhotometricInterpretation entry whose count is not 1 (TIFFFetchNormalTag: Incorrect count for "PhotometricInterpretation"; tag ignored), so for this file TIFFGetField(tiff, TIFFTAG_PHOTOMETRIC, …) returns 0 and libtiff treats the data as one 8-bit sample per pixel: TIFFTileSize() = 256, TIFFTileRowSize() = 16.

Pillow keeps the first value and carries on:

# src/PIL/TiffImagePlugin.py:762-770  (ImageFileDirectory_v2._setitem, reached from load())
            try:
                (dest[tag],) = values
            except ValueError:
                # We've got a builtin tag with 1 expected entry
                warnings.warn(f"Metadata Warning, tag {tag} had too many entries: ...")
                dest[tag] = values[0]

so _setup() sees photo == 6. OPEN_INFO[(II, 6, (1,), 1, (8,), ())] is ("L", "L"), and because the file is compressed the libtiff branch then overrides the rawmode:

# src/PIL/TiffImagePlugin.py:1578, 1600-1607
        self.use_load_libtiff = READ_LIBTIFF or self._compression != "raw"
        …
            if photo == 6:
                self._mode = "RGB"
                if self._compression in "jpeg" and self._planar_configuration == 1:
                    rawmode = "RGB"
                else:
                    rawmode = "RGBX"

RGBX is a 32-bit rawmode, so get_unpacker() (src/decode.c:301-309) sets state->bits = 32 and state->shuffle = copy4. The intent of the photo == 6 override is that libtiff will deliver RGBA through TIFFRGBAImage, but that decision is made in C from libtiff's reading of the tag, which here is "not YCbCr":

// src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c:737-764
    TIFFGetField(tiff, TIFFTAG_PHOTOMETRIC, &photometric);   // unset -> stays 0
    …
    readAsRGBA = photometric == PHOTOMETRIC_YCBCR;          // 0
    …
        if (TIFFIsTiled(tiff)) {
            _decodeTile(im, state, tiff, planes, unpackers); // unpackers[0] = copy4

The missing check

_decodeTile() only guards against libtiff's tile being larger than what the unpacker expects, then allocates exactly TIFFTileSize() bytes and feeds row_byte_size-strided rows to the shuffler:

// src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c:403-487  (_decodeTile)
    tile_bytes_size = TIFFTileSize(tiff);                      // 256
    …
    row_byte_size = TIFFTileRowSize(tiff);                     // 16
    …
    if (tile_bytes_size > ((tile_length * state->bits / planes + 7) / 8) * tile_width) {
        // 256 > 1024 is false -> no abort
        …
    }
    state->bytes = tile_bytes_size;
    new_data = realloc(state->buffer, state->bytes);           // 256-byte buffer (line 448)
    …
                for (tile_y = 0; tile_y < current_tile_length; tile_y++) {
                    shuffler(                                   // copy4: reads current_tile_width*4 = 64 bytes
                        (UINT8 *)im->image[tile_y + y] + x * im->pixelsize,
                        state->buffer + tile_y * row_byte_size, // from offset 16*tile_y
                        current_tile_width
                    );

Row tile_y is read from [16·tile_y, 16·tile_y + 64); for tile_y = 13, 14, 15 that ends 16, 32, 48 bytes past the 256-byte allocation. In general the last rows of every tile over-read by up to (state->bits / libtiff_bits_per_pixel − 1) × row_byte_size bytes, and row_byte_size scales with the attacker-chosen TileWidth.

Note also that the existing one-sided check at line 434 multiplies the file-controlled tile_width/tile_length (UINT32, accepted up to INT_MAX at line 428) by state->bits in 32-bit unsigned arithmetic, so tile_width * state->bits wraps for tile_width ≥ 2^32 / bits (2^26 for the 64-bit rawmodes, 2^27 for RGBX/I;32/F;32F). An 8 KB file declaring a 2,097,152×1 image with TILEWIDTH = 2^26+16, TILELENGTH = 1, 1-bit data for libtiff and RGBA;16N for Pillow makes libtiff allocate an ~8 MB tile from which unpackRGBA16L reads 16 MB, and the stock build SIGSEGVs in unpackRGBA16L ← _decodeTile (TiffDecode.c:483); a row-size comparison written in the same 32-bit arithmetic as line 434 would evaluate that row to 128 bytes and still accept it, so the new check must be done in a 64-bit type.

Compare the strip path, which refuses this situation (added for OSS-Fuzz crash-0da0 in 8.2.0):

// src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c:528-548  (_decodeStrip)
    unpacker_row_byte_size = (state->xsize * state->bits / planes + 7) / 8;
    …
    row_byte_size = TIFFScanlineSize(tiff);
    // if the unpacker calculated row size is > row byte size, (at least) the last
    // row of the strip will have a read buffer overflow.
    if (row_byte_size == 0 || unpacker_row_byte_size > row_byte_size) {
        state->errcode = IMAGING_CODEC_BROKEN;
        return -1;
    }

The identical file written with one strip instead of one tile fails load() with OSError: decoder error -2 because of this check.

Same gap in _decodeAsRGBA()

_decodeAsRGBA() always produces img.width * 4 bytes per row (TiffDecode.c:325, buffer allocated at line 339) and unpacks with state->shuffle (line 373) without looking at state->bits. It is reached when libtiff sees YCbCr while Pillow does not force RGBX. libtiff marks later duplicates of a tag as ignored (first occurrence wins); Pillow's ImageFileDirectory_v2.load() overwrites (TiffImagePlugin.py:945, last wins). The reproducer's ycbcr_dup.tif is a 16x16 Deflate strip with PhotometricInterpretation present twice (6, then 2) and BitsPerSample twice (8,8,8, then 16,16,16): libtiff decodes 8-bit YCbCr into a 1024-byte RGBA raster, Pillow selects RGB;16N (state->bits = 48), and unpackRGB16L reads 96 bytes per 64-byte row — ASan reports heap-buffer-overflow in unpackRGB16L (Unpack.c:609) from TiffDecode.c:373, past the 1024-byte region from TiffDecode.c:339.

The count-2 encoding is not the only lever, and on released versions it is not a lever at all: a 1-sample photo == 6 file only gets rawmode RGBX since the unreleased commit 155330d63 ("Do not open YCbCr colorspace images as RGB without libtiff (#9779)", 2026-08-26). Released versions are reached through duplicated tags instead. A 3-sample tiled file with two PhotometricInterpretation entries (1 or 2, then 6) produces the same copy4 ← _decodeTile over-read, since libtiff keeps the first value and decodes 3 bytes per pixel while Pillow keeps 6 and unpacks 4 (the reproducer's tile_dup.tif). ycbcr_dup.tif above reaches _decodeAsRGBA() the same way.

Impact

Any application that calls Image.open() + load() (or thumbnail(), convert(), save(), …) on an untrusted file reaches this with default settings: the file is content-sniffed as TIFF, and any compressed TIFF is decoded through libtiff and TiffDecode.c without READ_LIBTIFF being set. The over-read bytes are copied into the image's pixel rows, so a service that returns a thumbnail, preview or converted image hands adjacent heap memory back to the uploader, heap pointer values included — up to three libtiff tile rows past the buffer for the RGBX-over-8-bit case, with the tile row length (TileWidth) chosen by the attacker. state->buffer is allocated once and reused for every tile, so each tile re-reads the same region past that one buffer; the distinct heap disclosed per image is about (unpacker_bpp / libtiff_bpp − 1) tile rows and does not grow with the tile count. With a wide tile the read runs off the mapping and the process segfaults instead (the 65536x16 case crashes the stock build in most runs, depending on what is mapped after the buffer), taking down the whole worker rather than one request. Writes go to the correctly sized Imaging rows, so this is disclosure / crash, not memory corruption.

This is the same family as CVE-2020-35654 (Pillow and libtiff interpreting a YCbCr IFD differently in TiffDecode.c); that fix and the later crash-0da0 fix closed the write and the strip-path read, but the tile path and the RGBA path still trust Pillow's rawmode over libtiff's row size. The tile-path gap was introduced in 1c295bf43c3a ("Check for dimensions and sizes to fit into int", 2021-01-25), which switched _decodeTile() from a buffer sized by Pillow's unpacker to TIFFTileSize()/TIFFTileRowSize(); it is first in Pillow 8.2.0. The _decodeAsRGBA() half dates from eb8c1206d6b1 ("Fix CVE-2020-35654 - OOB Write in TiffDecode.c"), first in 8.1.0.

Reproducing

Run repro (a single Python 3 script) against the installed, unmodified Pillow. No sanitizer build is needed. It writes four TIFFs into a temporary directory, decodes each one in a child process, and removes the directory at the end.

The script writes its TIFFs byte by byte with a small classic-TIFF writer. Each file has a single IFD and a single Deflate-compressed block. Deflate is only there so the file is decoded by libtiff and TiffDecode.c. Every pixel byte in the compressed data is defined, so the decoded image should not depend on anything else in the process:

• tile_count2.tif: a 16x16, 1-sample, 8-bit tile with PhotometricInterpretation written as SHORT count 2, (6, 6). Pillow keeps 6 and unpacks with copy4 (RGBX, 4 bytes per pixel). libtiff ignores the tag and decodes 1 byte per pixel. This lever needs 155330d63 (unreleased).
• tile_dup.tif: a 16x16, 3-sample, 8-bit tile with PhotometricInterpretation present twice, 2 then 6. libtiff keeps 2 (RGB, 3 bytes per pixel) and Pillow keeps 6 (RGBX, 4 bytes per pixel). This variant also applies to released versions.
• ycbcr_dup.tif: the 16x16 strip with BitsPerSample 8,8,8 then 16,16,16 and PhotometricInterpretation 6 then 2. libtiff decodes 8-bit YCbCr through _decodeAsRGBA() (4 bytes per pixel), and Pillow unpacks RGB;16N with unpackRGB16L (6 bytes per pixel).
• tile_big.tif: the tile_count2.tif layout with a single 65536x16 tile.

For each of the first three files, the script runs Image.open() + load() + tobytes() twice, once with MALLOC_PERTURB_=85 and once with =170. If the two outputs differ, bytes from beyond the decode buffer have become pixels. In that case it prints the first differing offset and the bytes around it from both runs. On this tree all three differ in their last rows: the aa/55 fill bytes show up, along with heap pointer bytes. The script then decodes tile_big.tif and checks for a SIGSEGV (exit status -11). If gdb is available, it prints the top frames: copy4 (Unpack.c:1290) ← _decodeTile (TiffDecode.c:483) ← ImagingLibTiffDecode. This crash depends on ASLR, so an occasional run may survive.

Each step prints which _imaging build it used and how Pillow opened the file (mode, size and rawmode). The script ends with a one-line summary. The last line is BUG if any file leaked heap bytes into its pixels or the big tile crashed the process. Otherwise it is OK.

Suggested fix

The attached patch restores the _decodeStrip() invariant (the unpacker's input row must fit inside libtiff's row) in the two sibling decoders in src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c, at the point where each one sizes its buffer:

• _decodeTile() computes unpacker_row_byte_size = ((tsize_t)tile_width * state->bits / planes + 7) / 8 (the tsize_t cast keeps the product out of 32-bit arithmetic, so the TILEWIDTH = 2^26+16 case above cannot wrap past the check on 64-bit builds). It reuses that value for the existing TIFFTileSize() sanity check, as _decodeStrip() does for strips. After that check and before the realloc, it fails with IMAGING_CODEC_BROKEN when unpacker_row_byte_size > row_byte_size (TIFFTileRowSize()).
• _decodeAsRGBA() fails with IMAGING_CODEC_BROKEN when state->bits > 32, because TIFFRGBAImage rows are always 32 bits per pixel. This check runs before TIFFRGBAImageBegin() and any allocation.

With the patch, the tile and RGBA files fail load() with OSError: decoder error -2, the same result the equivalent strip file already gets. The patch also adds a regression test to Tests/test_file_libtiff.py (test_unpacker_row_wider_than_libtiff_row). The test embeds the count-2 tile and the duplicated-tag YCbCr strip as base64, following the file's existing convention. The patch was applied to a clean tree and rebuilt: the reproducer no longer triggers, and Tests/test_file_tiff.py, Tests/test_file_libtiff.py and Tests/test_tiff_crashes.py pass.

These checks close the over-read however the two parsers are made to disagree. Separately, _setup() could stop deriving the libtiff rawmode from tags that libtiff will read differently — e.g. treat a PhotometricInterpretation/BitsPerSample/Compression that is not a single well-typed value as "unknown pixel mode", the way ImageWidth/ImageLength are already required to be int at TiffImagePlugin.py:1473, or have ImageFileDirectory_v2.load() keep the first occurrence of a repeated tag as libtiff does (a behaviour change for malformed IFDs that is better made deliberately and separately) — but that only narrows the ways to reach the C-side gap rather than removing it: TiffImagePlugin cannot know how libtiff will resolve every malformed directory, and the decoder-side comparisons are what actually bound the read.

The patch

Reject TIFFs whose unpacker row is wider than libtiff's decoded row in _decodeTile() and _decodeAsRGBA(), as _decodeStrip() already does

Applies to src/libImaging/TiffDecode.c at the commit above.

diff --git a/Tests/test_file_libtiff.py b/Tests/test_file_libtiff.py
index 3d804ea4a..c08dfe77c 100644
--- a/Tests/test_file_libtiff.py
+++ b/Tests/test_file_libtiff.py
@@ -1232,6 +1232,50 @@ class TestFileLibTiff(LibTiffTestCase):
             with pytest.raises(OSError, match="decoder error -9"):
                 im.load()
 
+    @pytest.mark.parametrize(
+        "data",
+        (
+            # 16x16 8-bit greyscale tile, with a PhotometricInterpretation tag that
+            # has two values. Pillow reads it as YCbCr (rawmode RGBX, 4 bytes/pixel)
+            # while libtiff ignores it and decodes 1 byte/pixel.
+            (
+                b"SUkqAAgAAAAKAAABBAABAAAAEAAAAAEBBAABAAAAEAAAAAIBAwABAAAACAAA"
+                b"AAMBAwABAAAACAAAAAYBAwACAAAABgAGABUBAwABAAAAAQAAAEIBBAABAAAA"
+                b"EAAAAEMBBAABAAAAEAAAAEQBBAABAAAAhgAAAEUBBAABAAAACwEAAAAAAAB4"
+                b"nAEAAf/+AAECAwQFBgcICQoLDA0ODxAREhMUFRYXGBkaGxwdHh8gISIjJCUm"
+                b"JygpKissLS4vMDEyMzQ1Njc4OTo7PD0+P0BBQkNERUZHSElKS0xNTk9QUVJT"
+                b"VFVWV1hZWltcXV5fYGFiY2RlZmdoaWprbG1ub3BxcnN0dXZ3eHl6e3x9fn+A"
+                b"gYKDhIWGh4iJiouMjY6PkJGSk5SVlpeYmZqbnJ2en6ChoqOkpaanqKmqq6yt"
+                b"rq+wsbKztLW2t7i5uru8vb6/wMHCw8TFxsfIycrLzM3Oz9DR0tPU1dbX2Nna"
+                b"29zd3t/g4eLj5OXm5+jp6uvs7e7v8PHy8/T19vf4+foAAQIDBJ9Bepo="
+            ),
+            # 16x16 strip with duplicated BitsPerSample and PhotometricInterpretation
+            # tags. libtiff keeps the first (8-bit YCbCr, read as